The New York Islanders will return to Nassau County when a new arena is built on the grounds of Belmont Park in Elmont. Renderings show what the redeveloped sports and entertainment complex could look like. (Courtesy of New York Arena Partners LLC)
ELMONT, N.Y. (AP) — It's hardly the Dodgers going to Los Angeles, but another major sports franchise is leaving Brooklyn. The New York Islanders, who moved from their suburban home to Brooklyn in 2015, have won a bid to build a new arena on the grounds of the Belmont Park horse track.
"The Islanders are back where they belong," Gov. Andrew Cuomo said Wednesday.
The Democratic governor said it was sad when the team left the Nassau Coliseum and went to Brooklyn's Barclays Center "because they were so much part of the identity and the character and the culture of Long Island."
The National Hockey League team beat out a bid from the New York City FC soccer team, which envisioned building a stadium on the site just east of New York City.
The Islanders played at the Nassau Coliseum from its inception in 1972 until 2015, winning the Stanley Cup every year from 1980 to 1983. The move to the Brooklyn arena was greeted with displeasure by fans, who always considered the team to be a Long Island staple. The team is last in average attendance this year in the league.
Not surprisingly, fans applauded the reports the team would be headed back across the city limits to Nassau County.
"It's long overdue," Matt Herbert said during the Islanders' 5-3 loss to Detroit on Tuesday night.
The Massapequa resident said he attends two or three games a season in Brooklyn, compared with 10 or 12 when the team played at the Coliseum. He expected to return to that number in the new arena.
"It'll be good for (the team) to come back home," he added. "(Barclays Center) is not ours, it feels like we're renting this. But that place will be ours. It'll be great."
The Islanders submitted a development bid for a portion of the Belmont complex in September with several partners, including owners of the New York Mets and Madison Square Garden.
Team owner Jon Ledecky, who joined Cuomo, NHL president Gary Bettman and others for Wednesday's announcement, said the new $1 billion facility will include a hotel and retail space.
"This will be more than an arena," he said. "This site will be the home of economic development."
The Islanders will stay in Brooklyn through the end of next season. No date was given for when the new arena will open.
The state-run Empire State Development Corp. announced in July a request for proposals to develop vacant and underutilized parking lots at the site of the racetrack. The state also solicited bids to develop the land in 2012 but wound up scrapping all proposals a year ago.