Caban claims victory in too-close-to-call primary for Queens district attorney

Image 1 of 3

The national fight between left-wing and moderate Democrats played out again Tuesday in New York City, where the closely watched Democratic primary for Queens district attorney was tantalizingly close deep into the vote count.

Late on election day, political newcomer Tiffany Caban, a public defender who says the criminal justice system is rigged against the poor, held a narrow lead over Queens Borough President Melinda Katz, a seasoned politician who was the favorite of the state's Democratic Party establishment.

At Caban's election night headquarters, raucous supporters celebrated as she claimed victory.

"When we started this thing, they said I was too young. They said I didn't look like a district attorney. They said we could not build a movement from the grass roots. They said we could not win. But we did it y'all," she said.

But the race might not be decided soon.

With 99 percent of precincts reporting, Caban led Katz by 1,090 votes, out of more than 85,000 votes counted. Election officials won't start counting absentee ballots until Monday. At least 3,400 of those ballots have been received and more could arrive in the next few days. The Associated Press deemed the race too close to call.

Katz told supporters just before 11 p.m. that "there's a lot more days" before the results will be known.

"We always knew this was going to be tough, if it wasn't tough, it wasn't a race," Katz said.

U.S. Rep. Gregory Meeks, a Katz supporter, said every vote should be counted before the race is decided.

The contest in Queens, a borough of nearly 2.4 million people, is serving as a dual referendum on criminal justice reform and progressive politics.

All the Democrats largely embraced changes that already have been implemented to some degree by the top prosecutors in Manhattan and Brooklyn, like reducing prosecutions for possession of small amounts of marijuana.

But Caban, 31, who identifies as a queer Latina, has promised to take things further, saying more radical reform was needed to change a cycle of mass incarceration. She has promised to stop prosecuting recreational drug use, prostitution and small-time crimes like subway fare evasion, and seek less punitive sentences for many felonies.

She's been endorsed by two presidential contenders, Sens. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts and Bernie Sanders of Vermont, as well as U.S. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, the newcomer whose primary defeat of a longtime incumbent in part of Queens and the Bronx a year ago this month electrified the party's left wing.

Katz, 53, has the backing of state and county party leaders like New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo as well as a host of unions. She's also a veteran politician with deep ties to Queens, having served in the state Assembly from 1994 to 1999 and on the City Council from 2002 to 2009.

Katz has never worked in criminal law, but was the best-financed candidate in the race. She had also promised major reforms to the district attorney's office, including curtailing prosecutions of women for prostitution.

Other candidates trailed far behind in the vote tallies, including former judge and Queens Assistant District Attorney Gregory Lasak, former District of Columbia Deputy Attorney General Mina Malik, former Nassau County Assistant District Attorney Betty Lugo, and former New York Deputy Attorney General Jose Nieves.

The winner will be favored to win the November general election to succeed longtime District Attorney Richard Brown. He died last month at age 86.

Either Katz or Caban would be the first woman to serve as Queens district attorney.