Firefighters were called to a residence shortly after 1 p.m., according to reports.
When emergency services arrived, the owner of the house said two Chihuahuas were inside.
Firefighters recovered the first dog in "good condition," while they administered oxygen to the second dog, whose health had deteriorated.
Firefighters said the fire ignited after food was left on the stove for too long.
Get breaking news alerts in the FOX5NY News app. It is FREE!